Соспарринговал Pachi с другими движками.
Как и раньше: чёрные-белые

Pachi_DCNN-gtp4zen+Zenith6
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -black "wine /home/INSTall/0Go/gtp4zen/gtp4zen.exe -z 6 -t 2 -T 120 -s 2147483647 -r 25"' -computer-both
gtp4zen6-Pachi 1-0 :22:35-3:04:29 231moves
gtp4zen6-Pachi 1-0 :19:52-2:40:50 199moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -white "wine /home/INSTall/0Go/gtp4zen/gtp4zen.exe -z 6 -t 2 -T 120 -s 2147483647 -r 25"' -computer-both
Pachi-gtp4zen6 0-1 1:29:46-:13:35 126moves
Pachi-gtp4zen6 0-1 3:26:51-:22:35 232moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi_DCNN-gtp4zen6 (0,6-0,7)+0,1-0,2 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN - gtp4zen+Zenith6: 0 - 4


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s-gtp4zen+Zenith6
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -black "wine /home/INSTall/0Go/gtp4zen/gtp4zen.exe -z 6 -t 2 -T 120 -s 2147483647 -r 25"' -computer-both
gtp4zen6-Pachi 0-1 :18:31-2:49:24 182moves
gtp4zen6-Pachi 0-1 :12:22-1:44:12 110moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -white "wine /home/INSTall/0Go/gtp4zen/gtp4zen.exe -z 6 -t 2 -T 120 -s 2147483647 -r 25"' -computer-both
Pachi-gtp4zen6 1-0 2:28:17-:16:50 163moves
Pachi-gtp4zen6 1-0 2:44:12-:18:37 183moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi_DCNN-gtp4zen6 (0,5-0,6)+(2,9-3,0)-0,2 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s - gtp4zen+Zenith6: 4 - 0


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s-Rayon
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -black "/home/Ray-nn/ray --komi 7.5 --const-time 120 --thread 2 --tree-size 131072 --pondering"' -computer-both
Raynn-Pachi 0-1 4:37:32-6:07:39 284moves
Raynn-Pachi 0-1 ::-5:00:32 240moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -white "/home/Ray-nn/ray --komi 7.5 --const-time 120 --thread 2 --tree-size 131072 --pondering"' -computer-both
Pachi-Raynn 1-0 3:01:14-2:17:45 147moves
Pachi-Raynn 1-0 3:14:32-3:41:34 187moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi_DCNN-Ray_nn (0,6-0,9)+(2,8-2,9)-5,3 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s - Rayon: 4 - 0


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s-Leela0110GTP
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -black "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Leela-Pachi 1-0 2:52:45-4:02:55 277moves
Leela-Pachi 0-1 4:38:09-3:32:52 330moves
Leela-Pachi 1-0 2:58:12-4:23:06 303moves
Leela-Pachi 1-0 2:04:07-2:50:28 187moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -white "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Pachi-Leela 0-1 3:07:40-2:15:46 208moves
Pachi-Leela 1-0 3:09:27-2:31:46 209moves
Pachi-Leela 1-0 2:50:43-1:53:49 191moves
Pachi-Leela 0-1 3:13:03-1:59:27 216moves
Типичное использование памяти Leela-Pachi_DCNN (0,04-0,05)-(0,4-0,5)+2,8 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s - Leela0110GTP: 3 - 5


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-Leela0110GTP
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -black "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Leela-Pachi 0-1 2:01:09-3:03:02 198moves
Leela-Pachi 0-1 2:10:23-3:10:55 208moves
Leela-Pachi 0-1 2:34:07-3:31:40 238moves
Leela-Pachi 0-1 3:04:58-4:05:45 294moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -white "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Pachi-Leela 0-1 3:44:10-3:00:18 248moves
Pachi-Leela 0-1 3:28:04-2:25:00 242moves
Pachi-Leela 0-1 4:00:30-2:47:28 268moves
Pachi-Leela 0-1 3:26:21-2:32:20 226moves
Типичное использование памяти Leela-Pachi_DCNN 0,04-(0,4-0,5)+3,9 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - Leela0110GTP: 4 - 4


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-SAI+527ae617c8a61caae4473a69b8eb1411175fc2c3bcd35d13ca42dbf5a98090fa
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "/home/SAI/sai-sai/sai -g -t 2 -r 25 -w /home/SAI/320MB/527ae617c8a61caae4473a69b8eb1411175fc2c3bcd35d13ca42dbf5a98090fa" -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"' -computer-both
SAI-Pachi 1-0 3:57:25-3:38:34 237moves
SAI-Pachi 1-0 4:21:20-3:58:28 261moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "/home/SAI/sai-sai/sai -g -t 2 -r 25 -w /home/SAI/320MB/527ae617c8a61caae4473a69b8eb1411175fc2c3bcd35d13ca42dbf5a98090fa" -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"' -computer-both
Pachi-SAI 0-1 3:23:29-3:39:21 220moves
Pachi-SAI 0-1 3:57:11-4:19:25 260moves
Типичное использование памяти SAI-Pachi_DCNN 0,5-(0,4-0,5)+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_katago_2core_4GB_noponder_115s+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - SAI+527ae617c8a61caae4473a69b8eb1411175fc2c3bcd35d13ca42dbf5a98090fa: 0 - 4


Результат в 2-х словах: Pachi не стал сильней предшевствующих версий; Pachi_DCNN, хотя и стал немного сильней, но от следующего более сильного движка (Zen) остался практически также далёк; Pachi_DCNN с помощью параметра "--modern-joseki" достиг силы игры Leela.

Обновил раздачу.

Итак, рейтинг движков го (без использования GPU) на сегодняшний день выглядит следующим образом:

Top level
1) KataGo
2) LeelaZero
3) SAI

High level
4) Leela; Pachi_DCNN(modern-joseki)
5) Rayon
6) Zenith
7) Pachi_DCNN
8) Hiratuka

Middle level
9) Pachi
10)Ray
11)MoGo

Скачал KataGo версии 1.16.4 и соспарринговал с предыдущими версиями.
Как и раньше: чёрные-белые

KataGo_v1.16.4+g170e_b10c128_s1141046784_d204142634-KataGo_v1.16.2+g170e_b10c128_s1141046784_d204142634
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 10MB/g170e-b10c128-s1141046784-d204142634.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 10MB/g170e-b10c128-s1141046784-d204142634.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 1-0 2:51:12-2:51:21 171moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 1-0 4:10:46-4:10:56 251moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 10MB/g170e-b10c128-s1141046784-d204142634.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 10MB/g170e-b10c128-s1141046784-d204142634.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 2:57:21-2:55:09 176moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 1-0 1:23:36-1:23:44 83moves
Типичное использование памяти KataGo_v1.16.4-KataGo_v1.16.2 (5,2-5,4)-(5,2-5,4) ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+g170e_b10c128_s1141046784_d204142634 - KataGo_v1.16.2+g170e_b10c128_s1141046784_d204142634: 3 - 1


KataGo_v1.16.4+g170e_b15c192_s1672170752_d466197061-KataGo_v1.16.2+g170e_b15c192_s1672170752_d466197061
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 40MB/g170e-b15c192-s1672170752-d466197061.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 40MB/g170e-b15c192-s1672170752-d466197061.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 2:06:21-2:04:08 124moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 3:00:27-2:58:18 178moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 2:38:23-2:36:13 156moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 3:14:28-3:12:21 192moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 40MB/g170e-b15c192-s1672170752-d466197061.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 40MB/g170e-b15c192-s1672170752-d466197061.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 3:22:34-3:20:18 200moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 5:00:40-4:58:33 298moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 3:22:27-3:20:15 200moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 1-0 2:22:10-2:22:21 141moves
Типичное использование памяти KataGo_v1.16.4-KataGo_v1.16.2 (5,0-5,2)-(5,0-5,2) ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+g170e_b15c192_s1672170752_d466197061 - KataGo_v1.16.2+g170e_b15c192_s1672170752_d466197061: 3 - 5


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b20c256x2_s5303129600_d1228401921-KataGo_v1.16.2+kata1_b20c256x2_s5303129600_d1228401921
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 80MB/kata1-b20c256x2-s5303129600-d1228401921.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 80MB/kata1-b20c256x2-s5303129600-d1228401921.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 1-0 3:10:19-3:10:45 187moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 3:18:44-3:16:20 194moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 1-0 2:37:55-2:38:18 155moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 80MB/kata1-b20c256x2-s5303129600-d1228401921.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 80MB/kata1-b20c256x2-s5303129600-d1228401921.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 1-0 4:07:01-4:07:32 243moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 1:55:34-1:53:25 112moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 2:09:52-2:07:33 126moves
Типичное использование памяти KataGo_v1.16.4-KataGo_v1.16.2 (5,1-5,2)-(5,1-5,2) ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b20c256x2_s5303129600_d1228401921 - KataGo_v1.16.2+kata1_b20c256x2_s5303129600_d1228401921: 4 - 2


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b18c384nbt_s9131461376_d4087399203.-KataGo_v1.16.2+kata1_b18c384nbt_s9131461376_d4087399203
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 160MB/kata1-b18c384nbt-s9131461376-d4087399203.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 160MB/kata1-b18c384nbt-s9131461376-d4087399203.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 3:15:26-3:13:21 188moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 1:28:39-1:26:30 84moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 1-0 2:22:03-2:22:08 137moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 160MB/kata1-b18c384nbt-s9131461376-d4087399203.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 160MB/kata1-b18c384nbt-s9131461376-d4087399203.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 1:41:04-1:38:59 96moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 2:49:13-2:46:47 162moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 1:17:08-1:13:41 72moves
Типичное использование памяти KataGo_v1.16.4-KataGo_v1.16.2 (5,1-5,2)-(5,1-5,2) ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b18c384nbt_s9131461376_d4087399203 - KataGo_v1.16.2+kata1_b18c384nbt_s9131461376_d4087399203: 4 - 2


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-KataGo_v1.16.2+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 1-0 3:02:17-3:03:05 167moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 1:20:44-1:18:01 72moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 1-0 4:37:25-4:37:49 255moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 2:55:10-2:52:57 160moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 1:20:16-1:17:57 72moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 1-0 2:08:12-2:08:53 117moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 1-0 1:44:10-1:44:53 95moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 1:38:15-1:34:56 88moves
Типичное использование памяти KataGo_v1.16.4-KataGo_v1.16.2 6,0-6,0 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - KataGo_v1.16.2+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859: 4 - 4


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b60c320_s6782286336_d3070935549-KataGo_v1.16.2+kata1_b60c320_s6782286336_d3070935549
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring_heavyweight.cfg -model 640MB/kata1-b60c320-s6782286336-d3070935549.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring_heavyweight.cfg -model 640MB/kata1-b60c320-s6782286336-d3070935549.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 1:21:51-1:19:20 74moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 1-0 3:30:22-3:31:32 195moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 3:20:33-3:17:37 184moves
v1.16.4-v1.16.2 0-1 1:35:04-1:32:31 86moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring_heavyweight.cfg -model 640MB/kata1-b60c320-s6782286336-d3070935549.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.2-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring_heavyweight.cfg -model 640MB/kata1-b60c320-s6782286336-d3070935549.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 2:50:47-2:48:07 156moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 1-0 1:47:22-1:47:54 99moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 0-1 3:39:54-3:37:18 202moves
v1.16.2-v1.16.4 1-0 2:34:46-2:35:35 143moves
Типичное использование памяти KataGo_v1.16.4-KataGo_v1.16.2 4,7-4,7 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b60c320_s6782286336_d3070935549 - KataGo_v1.16.2+kata1_b60c320_s6782286336_d3070935549: 3 - 5


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b20c256x2_s5303129600_d1228401921-KataGo_v1.15.3+kata1_b20c256x2_s5303129600_d1228401921
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 80MB/kata1-b20c256x2-s5303129600-d1228401921.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.15.3-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 80MB/kata1-b20c256x2-s5303129600-d1228401921.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.4-v1.15.3 0-1 1:39:34-1:37:07 96moves
v1.16.4-v1.15.3 1-0 1:22:57-1:23:24 81moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 80MB/kata1-b20c256x2-s5303129600-d1228401921.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.15.3-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 80MB/kata1-b20c256x2-s5303129600-d1228401921.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.15.3-v1.16.4 0-1 2:57:06-2:54:49 172moves
v1.15.3-v1.16.4 0-1 2:42:58-2:40:28 158moves
Типичное использование памяти KataGo_v1.16.4-KataGo_v1.15.3 5,2-(5,1-5,2) ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b20c256x2_s5303129600_d1228401921 - KataGo_v1.15.3+kata1_b20c256x2_s5303129600_d1228401921: 3 - 1


KataGo_v1.14.1+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.14.1-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.14.1-v1.16.4 0-1 1:27:45-1:23:35 76moves
v1.14.1-v1.16.4 0-1 1:14:22-1:10:31 64moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.14.1-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.4-v1.14.1 1-0 3:12:26-3:15:16 173moves
v1.16.4-v1.14.1 0-1 2:05:47-2:04:58 112moves
Типичное использование памяти KataGo_v1.14.1-KataGo_v1.16.4 6,0-6,0 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - KataGo_v1.14.1+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859: 3 - 1


KataGo_v1.13.0+kata1_b60c320_s6782286336_d3070935549-KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b60c320_s6782286336_d3070935549
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.13.0-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring_heavyweight.cfg -model 640MB/kata1-b60c320-s6782286336-d3070935549.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring_heavyweight.cfg -model 640MB/kata1-b60c320-s6782286336-d3070935549.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.13.0-v1.16.4 0-1 2:43:09-2:39:29 146moves
v1.13.0-v1.16.4 0-1 2:36:10-2:33:03 140moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.13.0-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring_heavyweight.cfg -model 640MB/kata1-b60c320-s6782286336-d3070935549.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring_heavyweight.cfg -model 640MB/kata1-b60c320-s6782286336-d3070935549.bin.gz"' -computer-both
v1.16.4-v1.13.0 1-0 2:21:54-2:23:08 129moves
v1.16.4-v1.13.0 0-1 2:41:29-2:40:42 146moves
Типичное использование памяти KataGo_v1.13.0-KataGo_v1.16.4 6,4-4,7 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b60c320_s6782286336_d3070935549 - KataGo_v1.13.0+kata1_b60c320_s6782286336_d3070935549: 3 - 1


Итак, последняя версия KataGo не слабей предыдущей (21 - 19) и сильней старых версий (9 - 3).

Соспарринговал Pachi 12.88.
Как и раньше: чёрные-белые

Pachi-Pachi_previous
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 2:53:38-2:51:10 220moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 2:24:47-2:19:47 180moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 3:32:52-3:27:59 268moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 3:25:25-3:26:14 261moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev (без скачков) 0,7-0,7 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi - Pachi_previous: 3 - 1


Pachi-Pachi_preprevious
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi_bin-12.84
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi-12.84-amd64 --nojoseki --nodcnn -f opening.dat -t 120 threads=2,max_tree_size=8192,resign_threshold=0.25,reportfreq=5s,pondering"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 2:31:32-2:37:35 195moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 3:08:01-3:12:23 241moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 2:41:02-2:39:38 204moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 2:38:15-2:34:17 197moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 3:36:01-3:33:27 275moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 3:39:37-3:39:17 281moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_pprev (без скачков) 0,7-(0,7-0,8) ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi - Pachi_preprevious: 4 - 2


Pachi_DCNN-Pachi_DCNN_previous
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 2:55:22-2:59:36 225moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 3:25:25-3:22:36 258moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 2:39:16-3:23:05 255moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 2:45:07-2:47:24 239moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 :49:22-2:28:25 185moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 2:53:24-2:00:14 212moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 3:40:19-3:25:16 309moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 2:41:28-2:36:22 200moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev (0,6-0,7)+0,1-0,6+0,1 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN - Pachi_DCNN_previous: 3 - 5


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki-Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi_bin-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 3:27:33-3:30:17 239moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 3:22:22-3:20:44 230moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 2:47:45-2:50:53 187moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 4:23:28-4:23:25 309moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev 0,6+3,0-(0,5-0,6)+3,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki - Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous: 3 - 1


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi_bin-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 2:44:26-2:46:40 184moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 3:28:29-3:31:06 237moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 3:47:21-3:42:39 256moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 3:36:18-3:32:24 244moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev (0,5-0,6)+(3,9-4,0)-(0,5-0,6)+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859: 1 - 3


Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki_previous+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"'
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55556 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"'
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55556"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 3:51:52-3:46:08 259moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 3:17:12-3:20:09 223moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55556"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 3:13:01-3:11:52 211moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 3:16:56-3:12:20 218moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev 0,6+4,0-0,6+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki_previous+KataGo_1.16.4kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859: 1 - 3


Pachi-Hiratuka
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -black "taskset -c 0,1 wine /home/INSTall/0Go/Hiratuka10_37B/Hiratuka-19x19.exe -po 7777777"' -computer-both
Hiratuka-Pachi 1-0 1:45:38-3:02:16 229moves
Hiratuka-Pachi 1-0 1:29:32-2:36:34 197moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -white "taskset -c 0,1 wine /home/INSTall/0Go/Hiratuka10_37B/Hiratuka-19x19.exe -po 7777777"' -computer-both
Pachi-Hiratuka 0-1 2:25:59-1:21:32 182moves
Pachi-Hiratuka 0-1 2:26:46-1:22:36 184moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Hiratuka (0,7-0,8)-(0,7-0,8) ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi - Hiratuka: 0 - 4


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki-Leela0110GTP
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -black "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Leela-Pachi 1-0 1:48:17-2:49:37 187moves
Leela-Pachi 0-1 1:57:01-2:48:34 188moves
Leela-Pachi 0-1 2:04:34-2:47:50 186moves
Leela-Pachi 1-0 2:31:54-3:33:12 241moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -white "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Pachi-Leela 1-0 2:55:58-2:04:32 197moves
Pachi-Leela 0-1 2:50:44-1:44:06 186moves
Pachi-Leela 0-1 3:02:02-1:58:58 202moves
Pachi-Leela 0-1 2:26:04-1:33:47 158moves
Типичное использование памяти Leela-Pachi_DCNN_mj (0,04-0,05)-0,5+2,9 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki - Leela0110GTP: 3 - 5


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki_previous+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55556 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"'
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55556"' -computer-both
Pachi_ej-Pachi 0-1 4:20:28-4:18:45 302moves
Pachi_ej-Pachi 1-0 2:59:08-3:02:22 199moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55556"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_ej 1-0 4:19:17-4:18:49 297moves
Pachi-Pachi_ej 1-0 3:21:44-3:13:17 215moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_ej (0,5-0,6)+4,0-0,6+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki_previous+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859: 1 - 3


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"'
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_ej-Pachi 0-1 2:55:54-2:50:34 190moves
Pachi_ej-Pachi 0-1 2:35:25-2:32:01 166moves
Pachi_ej-Pachi 1-0 3:37:13-3:39:28 247moves
Pachi_ej-Pachi 0-1 4:24:06-4:17:14 302moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_ej 0-1 2:53:02-2:50:37 188moves
Pachi-Pachi_ej 0-1 4:21:49-4:19:24 302moves
Pachi-Pachi_ej 1-0 3:48:34-3:48:04 261moves
Pachi-Pachi_ej 1-0 3:29:29-3:33:47 239moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_ej 0,6+4,0-(0,5-0,6)+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859: 3 - 5


Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki_previous+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-Leela0110GTP
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55556 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"'
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55556" -black "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Leela-Pachi 0-1 1:58:52-2:32:38 170moves
Leela-Pachi 1-0 2:21:00-3:54:01 263moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55556" -white "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Pachi-Leela 1-0 2:10:56-1:40:00 143moves
Pachi-Leela 1-0 2:24:31-1:54:49 155moves
Типичное использование памяти Leela-Pachi_DCNN_mej_b28c512 0,06-0,5+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki_previous+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - Leela0110GTP: 3 - 1


Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-Leela0110GTP
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz"'
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555" -black "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Leela-Pachi 0-1 2:26:33-3:14:35 216moves
Leela-Pachi 0-1 2:36:30-3:33:44 240moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555" -white "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Pachi-Leela 1-0 4:41:26-3:13:23 327moves
Pachi-Leela 1-0 2:19:40-1:35:42 155moves
Типичное использование памяти Leela-Pachi_DCNN_mej_b28c512 0,06-0,5+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - Leela0110GTP: 4 - 0


Основной итог: данная версия в целом не сильней предыдущей, а Pachi c modern external joseki KataGo 1.16.4 даже немного сильней Leela (не Zero!).

Рейтинг движков для игры в го (без использования ГПУ) выглядит следующим образом:

Top level
1) KataGo
2) LeelaZero
3) SAI

High level
4) Pachi_DCNN(modern_external-joseki_katago)
5) Leela

Middle level
6) Rayon
7) Zenith
8) Pachi(default)
9) Hiratuka

Low level
10) Pachi(nojoseki,nodcnn)
11) Ray
12) MoGo

Соспарринговал лучшие (согласно ELO рейтингу) за 2025 г. файлы весов KataGo.
Как и раньше: чёрные-белые

KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s7168446720-d4316919285.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:37:09-1:34:13 86moves
b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:59:18-1:56:23 106moves
b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 1-0 3:05:50-3:07:15 169moves
b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 2:16:22-2:13:37 122moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s7168446720-d4316919285.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285 0-1 2:54:05-2:50:30 156moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285 0-1 1:21:27-1:18:38 72moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285 1-0 1:46:31-1:47:29 97moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285 1-0 1:46:41-1:47:45 97moves
Типичное использование памяти kata1_b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 6,0-6,0 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285 - KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M: 3 - 5


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 2:03:26-2:00:43 110moves
b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 2:27:05-2:23:59 132moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 1-0 1:54:08-1:55:31 103moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 0-1 3:45:53-3:43:29 204moves
Типичное использование памяти kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 6,0-6,0 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M: 1 - 3


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8121048832-d4572687465.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:53:38-1:51:07 102moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:47:07-1:44:13 96moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8121048832-d4572687465.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 1-0 3:00:14-3:00:45 165moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 2:17:53-2:14:40 124moves
Типичное использование памяти kata1_b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 6,0-6,0 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 - KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M: 1 - 3


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s7168446720-d4316919285.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s12163512064-d5648012427.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 0-1 1:30:08-1:27:12 80moves
b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 0-1 3:21:27-3:20:10 184moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s7168446720-d4316919285.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s12163512064-d5648012427.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427-b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285 1-0 2:27:50-2:28:36 135moves
b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427-b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285 0-1 2:57:38-2:54:26 160moves
Типичное использование памяти kata1_b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285-kata1_b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 6,0-6,0 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s7168446720_d4316919285 - KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427: 1 - 3


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d15648012427
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s12163512064-d5648012427.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 0-1 2:00:14-1:57:21 108moves
b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 0-1 1:20:04-1:18:08 72moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8032072448-d4548958859.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s12163512064-d5648012427.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427-b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 0-1 2:28:45-2:25:44 134moves
b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427-b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 1-0 2:30:33-2:30:31 137moves
Типичное использование памяти kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859-kata1_b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 6,0-6,0 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8032072448_d4548958859 - KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427: 1 - 3


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8121048832-d4572687465.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s12163512064-d5648012427.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 0-1 1:20:57-1:18:06 72moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 0-1 1:21:15-1:18:09 72moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 0-1 2:21:00-2:18:10 126moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 0-1 1:27:56-1:25:18 78moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s8121048832-d4572687465.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s12163512064-d5648012427.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 1:34:52-1:31:51 84moves
b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 3:21:18-3:19:17 182moves
b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 2:16:32-2:13:58 122moves
b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 2:41:11-2:38:24 144moves
Типичное использование памяти kata1_b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-kata1_b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427 6,0-6,0 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 - KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s12163512064_d5648012427: 4 - 4


KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M
Рабочий путь: /home/KataGo
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s12163512064-d5648012427.bin.gz" -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:46:28-1:43:31 94moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:28:26-1:25:36 78moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 1-0 3:01:56-3:02:06 165moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 2:47:46-2:44:19 150moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:22:20-1:18:49 72moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:21:15-1:18:11 72moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:54:50-1:53:06 104moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:36:11-1:32:56 86moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 2:21:25-2:19:23 128moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:20:15-1:18:11 72moves
b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 0-1 1:25:31-1:22:54 76moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-s12163512064-d5648012427.bin.gz" -black "./katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config gtp_sparring.cfg -model 320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"' -computer-both
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 2:20:32-2:17:10 126moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 1-0 3:08:15-3:09:11 171moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 2:05:06-2:02:34 112moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 1-0 1:49:05-1:49:24 99moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 1:49:02-1:46:23 98moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 1-0 3:58:02-3:57:57 217moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 1-0 2:19:25-2:20:03 127moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 1:41:13-1:38:25 90moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 1-0 2:52:25-2:53:05 157moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 1-0 3:14:15-3:14:52 177moves
b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 0-1 1:21:35-1:51:01 74moves
Типичное использование памяти kata1_b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465-kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M 6,0-6,0 ГБ

Таким образом, KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_s8121048832_d4572687465 - KataGo_v1.16.4+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M: 6 - 16


Основным итогом является то, что лишь за 2 года "полутяжи" KataGo стали сильней более, чем на погрешность (21-11), но при этом "осенний" явно сильней (16-6) финального годового (несмотря на практически одинаковый рейтинг ELO на основе "синтетических" тестов).
На мой взгляд уже давно пора запускать "тяжеловеса", естественно, с подобранным оптимальным размером блока (вместо старого с неоптимальным соотношением "b" и "c").

Обновил раздачу

Рейтинг победителей "весовых категорий" нейросетей KataGo на данный момент следующий:

"наилегчайшая" <|= 2 ^ 23 Б (< 12 МиБ) - g170e-b10c128-s1141046784-d204142634.bin (6)
"полулёгкая" 2 ^ 24 Б (12 - 24 МиБ) - у меня отсутствует
"лёгкая" 2 ^ 25 Б (24 - 48 МиБ) - g170e-b15c192-s1672170752-d466197061.bin (5)
"полусредняя" 2 ^ 26 Б (48 - 96 МиБ) - g170e|kata1-b20c256x2-s5303129600-d1228401921.bin (4)
"средняя" 2 ^ 27 Б (96 - 192 МиБ) - kata1-b18c384nbt-s9131461376-d4087399203.bin (2)
"полутяжёлая" 2 ^ 28 Б (192 - 384 МиБ) - kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin (1)
"тяжёлая" 2 ^ 29 Б (384 - 768 МиБ) - kata1-b60c320-s6782286336-d3070935549.bin (3)
"сверхтяжёлая" >|= 2 ^ 30 Б (> 768 МиБ) - у меня отсутствует

Соспарринговал Pachi 12.90.
Как и раньше: чёрные-белые

Pachi-Pachi_previous
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 3:37:57-3:34:36 274moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 3:14:11-3:15:09 247moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --nojoseki --nodcnn -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 3:00:31-3:01:03 229moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 2:42:53-2:43:40 207moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev (без скачков) 0,7-(0,6-0,7) ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi - Pachi_previous: 1 - 3


Pachi_DCNN-Pachi_DCNN_previous
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 2:31:03-2:00:32 186moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 3:11:46-3:13:35 243moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 2:52:58-1:28:16 214moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 2:16:23-1:47:56 170moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 3:12:19-3:06:38 238moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 :57:13-2:33:06 221moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 2:33:18-:54:40 188moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 2:15:36-3:11:10 244moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev (0,6-0,7)+0,1-(0,6-0,7)+0,1 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN - Pachi_DCNN_previous: 4 - 4


Pachi_DCNN-Pachi_DCNN_preprevious
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.86
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_pprev-Pachi 1-0 2:47:14-2:49:39 213moves
Pachi_pprev-Pachi 0-1 3:55:18-3:50:31 294moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_pprev 1-0 2:48:37-3:16:45 245moves
Pachi-Pachi_pprev 1-0 3:19:15-3:23:17 255moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_pprev (0,6-0,7)+0,1-0,6+0,1 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN - Pachi_DCNN_preprevious: 3 - 1


Pachi_DCNN-gtp4zen+Zenith6
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -black "wine /home/INSTall/0Go/gtp4zen/gtp4zen.exe -z 6 -t 2 -T 120 -s 2147483647 -r 25"' -computer-both
gtp4zen6-Pachi 1-0 :21:54-2:58:11 223moves
gtp4zen6-Pachi 1-0 :16:58-2:11:50 165moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=8192 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering" -white "wine /home/INSTall/0Go/gtp4zen/gtp4zen.exe -z 6 -t 2 -T 120 -s 2147483647 -r 25"' -computer-both
Pachi-gtp4zen6 1-0 3:32:55-:25:57 269moves
Pachi-gtp4zen6 0-1 2:15:30-:16:48 164moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi_DCNN-gtp4zen6 0,7+0,1-0,2 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN - gtp4zen+Zenith6: 1 - 3


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki-Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi_bin-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 3:38:58-3:37:57 250moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 3:15:30-3:10:21 218moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 4:13:57-4:13:31 297moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 2:52:17-2:54:10 193moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev 0,7+3,0-0,6+(2,9-3,0) ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki - Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous: 0 - 4


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi_bin-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 4:29:27-4:26:34 314moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 3:25:40-3:22:16 228moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 3:22:57-3:17:50 219moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 1-0 3:04:46-3:09:07 207moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev 0,6+4,0-(0,5-0,6)+(3,9-4,0) ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M - Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M: 0 - 4


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_prev+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-Leela0110GTP
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz" -black "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Leela-Pachi 1-0 2:32:41-3:37:41 241moves
Leela-Pachi 1-0 ::-:: 191moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz" -white "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0"' -computer-both
Pachi-Leela 1-0 3:58:30-2:30:11 263moves
Pachi-Leela 0-1 3:02:22-2:09:42 202moves
Типичное использование памяти Leela-Pachi_DCNN_mj_prev 0,04-(0,4-0,5)+(3,9-4,0) ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_prev+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M - Leela0110GTP: 1 - 3

Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki_previous+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"'
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55556 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"'
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55556"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_prev 1-0 3:47:28-3:49:21 259moves
Pachi-Pachi_prev 0-1 3:59:32-3:56:08 274moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55556"' -computer-both
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 3:56:56-3:52:45 270moves
Pachi_prev-Pachi 0-1 2:54:47-2:51:48 192moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_prev 0,6+4,0-(0,5-0,6)+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M - Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki_previous+KataGo_1.16.4kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M: 3 - 1


Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"'
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_ej-Pachi 0-1 3:21:33-3:18:28 224moves
Pachi_ej-Pachi 1-0 4:02:34-3:56:21 269moves
Pachi_ej-Pachi 1-0 3:26:13-3:29:39 235moves
Pachi_ej-Pachi 1-0 4:31:55-:: 305moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Pachi_ej 0-1 3:29:52-3:28:36 236moves
Pachi-Pachi_ej 1-0 2:51:36-2:54:05 189moves
Pachi-Pachi_ej 1-0 4:04:24-4:05:33 283moves
Pachi-Pachi_ej 0-1 3:49:22-3:44:53 260moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi-Pachi_ej (0,5-0,6)+4,0-(0,5-0,6)+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M - Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M: 5 - 3


Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi_bin-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"'
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi-12.88
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -white "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_mej-Pachi_mj_prev 0-1 3:19:16-3:16:25 222moves
Pachi_mej-Pachi_mj_prev 1-0 3:50:20-3:53:41 267moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -black "./pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --kata-config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg --kata-model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi_mj_prev-Pachi_mej 0-1 2:37:01-2:34:41 172moves
Pachi_mj_prev-Pachi_mej 0-1 3:41:00-3:34:24 246moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi_mej-Pachi_mj_prev (0,5-0,6)+4,0-(0,5-0,6)+4,0 ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M - Pachi_DCNN_modern_joseki_previous+kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M: 3 - 1


Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M-Leela0110GTP
Рабочий путь: /home/Pachi/Pachi_bin-12.90
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-server.jar -verbose -port 55555 -loop './pachi --modern-joseki -t 120 threads=2 max_tree_size=3072 resign_threshold=0.25 reportfreq=5s pondering --external-joseki "/home/KataGo/katago-v1.16.4-eigen-linux-x64/katago gtp -config katago-2core_4GB_noponder.cfg -model /home/KataGo/320MB/kata1-b28c512nbt-adam-s10940M-d5325M.bin.gz"'
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -white "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0" -black "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Pachi-Leela 0-1 4:02:38-2:27:55 272moves
Pachi-Leela 0-1 3:26:35-2:22:49 228moves
Pachi-Leela 1-0 4:36:35-3:42:09 317moves
Команда: java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui.jar -komi 7.5 -program 'java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-twogtp.jar -verbose -komi 7.5 -time 1s+2/1 -black "/home/Leela0110GTP/leela_0110_linux_x64 -g -t 2 -b 0" -white "java -jar /usr/share/gogui/lib/gogui-client.jar localhost 55555"' -computer-both
Leela-Pachi 0-1 2:17:58-3:13:25 216moves
Leela-Pachi 0-1 2:03:29-2:57:36 196moves
Leela-Pachi 0-1 1:58:25-2:54:29 192moves
Типичное использование памяти Pachi_mej-Leela 0,5+4,0-(0,06-0,07) ГБ

Таким образом, Pachi_DCNN_modern_external_joseki+KataGo_1.16.4_kata1_b28c512nbt_adam_s10940M_d5325M - Leela0110GTP: 4 - 2


Подытоживая: Pachi последней версии проиграл предыдущим 14-18, из них 0-8 с modern-joseki и прилагаемым joseki движком.
Уточнение рейтинга:

Наивысший уровень
1) KataGo
2) LeelaZero
3) SAI

Высокий уровень
4) Pachi_DCNN(modern,external_katago1.16.4-joseki)
5) Leela
6) Pachi_DCNN(modern-joseki)

Средний уровень
7) Rayon
8) Zenith
9) Pachi_DCNN(default)
10)Hiratuka

Низкий уровень
11)Pachi(nojoseki,nodcnn)
12)Ray
13)MoGo